M Gel/Cream Eyeliner Tool Smudge Proof Matte Black Eye-liner Pencil Tattoo Eyeliner Pen, Eyeliner Gel Stick Makeup Eye-liners for Women Girls (Black)

I wore this at home on one eye ( I also got a new mascara and tried that on the other eye) and wore both on each eye to see if it fell. If it did, I would know which one made me look like a raccoon at the end of the day. To my surprise, none did. I even went to bed with them on and woke up with clean eyes. It is so easy to put on, lasts a long time, and has a nice texture. It is not waterproof because it washes off easily.

Worked well

This is a liner that pops from the initial application. I only have to draw one line on the waterline of my eyes. It's color is deep and rich and very black. It works for me.

Good quality, color is accurate, very functional, shimmer is the hardest to clean, other than that all of them are easy to clean, texture is good, could be milkier but you get what you pay for . Long wear.

I have been in need of a wide/thick black eyeliner ever since Flower stopped making theirs. I love that this one glides on easy gives me the nice thick line I want. However, it is not water-proof nor sweat proof. It will smear easily. I will still be on the hunt for a thick eyeliner that is water proof.

The best eyeliner I love it

It glides on very smooth and its color is pigmented. If only it was actually long use wear and smear resistant like advertised.It applies so easily but comes off just as easy. Throughout the day you will have raccoon eyes with this.Did not irritate my eyes or come broken.

This would be a 5 star product IF the lid would stay on it and IF it didn't waste so much having no way to sharpen except to rub it on paper to get a point on it. There isn't much product there to start with and i hate having to waste any just to get a good point. Beyond that, its great, nice and soft so no dragging and pulling at my eyes...at 50 i don't need anything to cause more wrinkles! Its easy to smudge for a smokey look or leave as is for sharp defined lines. Stays put throughout a normal day, then comes off easily with the baby shampoo i use to wash my face. Would definitely recommend this eyeliner crayon! I've also used as a lipstick, but it doesn't last long on lips.