NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPJumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner Pencil - Milk (White)

UPDATE I reread the description and in huge print with pictures tells you THIS PENCIL GOES TROUGH THE PENCIL SHARPENER! Someone said in comments the same thing I thought except they pulled the back off and pushed through with a Q Tip. It appears to be solid plastic! It’s not! Use pencil sharpener!Once the crayon is worn down there is no way to twist it to get anymore fed out. I’m not sure if I got a bad pencil or it doesn’t give you anymore than the tip it comes with. Hard to explain. Does not have a way to feed the crayon through in plastic case. I wanted to replace an actual pencil I’ve had for a long time. It is a wooden pencil with cream shadow that you use a pencil sharpener with. The new modern version not in wood but now plastic doesn't open to add more tip. It doesn’t work. Shadow is great but can’t use more than the tip it came open too. I’m not happy with this at all.

These are fantastic. I’m a certified MUA, and I really love these in brown. They are wonderfully soft, but not too soft, and are perfect when you want to smudge the line. Last long, also. I really love these on clients over 60- no hard lines, just a softer look.

I should have read the details more closely, this is just a large eyeliner pencil, not a cream-to-powder type of pencil. It's ok for what it is...quite greasy, smudges easily. I bought the Frappe colour, basic brown colour - not dark unless you put lots on.

Now this, for a cheaper alternative, is very good…blended beautifully, good color, has a lot more bronze than shown in pictures

I didn't realize this was a flat color. I mean there's no shimmer to it at all. It glides on well and I blend it with a brush. It doesn't seem to run into creases which is good. But I would not buy again because there's no shimmer

Lasts a long whileCan apply thinly or wider

Goes on smoothly and last for a while

I’m amazed at how much this illuminates my inner eye area and makes me look so much more awake. It is really nice. Definitely a staple and great quality.